Improving the Validity of Letters of Recommendation: An Investigation of Three Standardized Reference Forms
Titel:
Improving the Validity of Letters of Recommendation: An Investigation of Three Standardized Reference Forms
Auteur:
McCarthy, Julie M. Goffin, Richard D.
Verschenen in:
Military psychology
Paginering:
Jaargang 13 (2001) nr. 4 pagina's 199-222
Jaar:
2001-10-01
Inhoud:
Although letters of recommendation are (LORs) widely used, little research has examined how accurately they predict job performance. The few existing studies have yielded mixed results, and meta-analytic estimates of validity range from .14 to .27 (Hunter & Hunter, 1984; Reilly & Chao, 1982). This investigation was designed to improve predictive validity by developing a standardized reference form and evaluating 3 different rating formats: Multi-Item scales, Relative Percentile Method (RPM) scales, and Global Trait Rankings. A total of 520 individuals applied to the Canadian military, and 544 LORs were obtained. Complete predictor and criterion data were available for 57 participants. Regression analyses indicated that the validity of the RPM rating format (R2(adj) = .18; R(adj) = .42) was substantially higher than previous estimates of LOR validity. The 2 remaining methods produced nonsignificant results. Limitations of the study, suggestions for future research, and implications for the field are discussed.
Tijdschrift beschrijving