Medical Hermeneutics of Murder. Race, Medicine and Law in a Murder Case from Finnmark, 1911
Titel:
Medical Hermeneutics of Murder. Race, Medicine and Law in a Murder Case from Finnmark, 1911
Auteur:
Skålevåg, Svein Atle
Verschenen in:
Acta borealia
Paginering:
Jaargang 24 (2007) nr. 2 pagina's 109-129
Jaar:
2007
Inhoud:
This article seeks to investigate the investigation of a murder case in Finnmark in 1911, where four siblings killed their young brother. In the legal investigations following the misdeed, a number of medical experts played a prominent role. Their role was to assess the mental condition of the defendants, but also to make sense of the murder. A specific interpretational mode was called for: a “medical hermeneutics” of the murder. The murder investigation becomes an occasion for discussing medical and juridical interpretations of human agency at the turn of the century, and especially of the role of the concept of “race” in these interpretations. For at least some of the physicians involved, the racial make-up of the ethnic group to which the actors belonged constituted an inevitable part of the context that made the act intelligible. Although the concept of race, and the conceptual frameworks offered by degenerationism and medical psychology to a certain degree made the act intelligible, these interpretational schemes had little to offer in terms of assessing the legal accountability of the defendants. Hence, the case illustrates the profound epistemological limits of medical interpretation in facing a legal case.
Tijdschrift beschrijving