Knowledge and Technique in Statistical Problem-Solving
Title:
Knowledge and Technique in Statistical Problem-Solving
Author:
Allwood, Carl-Martin Montgomery, Henry
Appeared in:
International journal of science education
Paging:
Volume 3 (1981) nr. 4 pages 431-450
Year:
1981-10
Contents:
English Subjects' knowledge and technique in statistical problem-solving, as well as their ability to detect their own problem-solving errors, were studied. Twenty subjects were asked to solve two statistical problems, and then to explain their solutions to the experimenter. Finally, each subject was asked successively more detailed questions about his/her solution, particularly in reference to its erroneous parts. The results showed that subjects tended to describe rather than explain their solutions. Subjects eliminated three errors (4%) when accounting for their solutions and another 20 errors (24%) in the following interview. About one-third of all errors were analysed as being due to deficiencies in subjects' problem-solving techniques. For 62% of the errors where subjects showed knowledge deficiencies, there were deficiencies in propositional knowledge, i.e. in subjects' understanding of statistical concepts and their interrelations. The results showed that misunderstandings of concepts and methods of solution were much more common than lack of conceptions as such. In addition, the results suggest that deficiencies in subjects' problem-solving are related to motivational factors, such as a tendency to minimize cognitive strain. Pedagogical implications of the results are discussed.
Journal description