Moral life as the obstacle to the development of ethical theory
Titel:
Moral life as the obstacle to the development of ethical theory
Auteur:
Birchall, B. C.
Verschenen in:
Inquiry
Paginering:
Jaargang 21 (1978) nr. 1-4 pagina's 409-424
Jaar:
1978
Inhoud:
It is often taken for granted that there is a crucial dichotomy between positive science, with its interest in what is the case, and morality, with its supposed interest in what ought to be the case. This assumption takes its departure from a belief in the notion of unconditional or categorical obligation or 'the moral' as 'that whose nature it is to be required or demanded'. The notion of unconditional or categorical obligation, together with the assumption that there is a dichotomy between considerations of what is the case and what ought to be the case, however widespread and entrenched this notion and assumption might be, are logically confused. But to demonstrate this logical confusion is not the only task confronting ethical theory. Another, and often neglected task, is to draw attention to the ethical origins of this confusion in a particular way of life. Hegel's distinction between Moralitat (Moral Life) and Sittlichkeit (Ethical Life) is of critical importance here. The obstacle to the development of ethical theory, then, is not some abstract 'logical confusion', but is, rather, the way of life (Moral Life) of which this confusion is a natural expression.
Tijdschrift beschrijving