Details van artikel 108 van 109 gevonden artikelen
Whatever Happened to Canadian Children's Equality Rights? A Reconsideration of the Eaton Special Education Case
Titel:
Whatever Happened to Canadian Children's Equality Rights? A Reconsideration of the Eaton Special Education Case
Auteur:
Grover, Sonja
Verschenen in:
Education & the law
Paginering:
Jaargang 14 (2002) nr. 4 pagina's 253-263
Jaar:
2002-12
Inhoud:
This paper reconsiders the Canadian Supreme Court Decision in Eaton and examines its implications for the equality rights of Canadian children in general. The suggestion is made that a 'best interest of the child' standard cannot be met if it involves the violation of fundamental Charter rights. Segregated special education placement, when against the wishes of the parents or guardians and with no s. 1 justification, it is argued, is unconstitutional. The latter gives rise to violations of equality provisions with regard to the student's freedom of association, the right to personal autonomy in decision-making for parents in regards to their child's education, as well as, in some cases, security of the person insofar as the psychological, social and cognitive development of the disabled child is concerned. Such an exclusion from the mainstream, if imposed, it is suggested, does not generally meet the test for 'reasonableness' in accommodation consistent with Charter guarantees. The presumption in favor of integration unless the parent or guardian wishes otherwise is, it is argued, a constitutional imperative based on Charter equality rights rather than a preference for one pedagogical theory (integration) over another (segregated special education placement).
Uitgever:
Routledge
Bronbestand:
Elektronische Wetenschappelijke Tijdschriften
Details van artikel 108 van 109 gevonden artikelen
Tijdschrift beschrijving