Development and political legitimacy: the cases of Iraq and Afghanistan
Titel:
Development and political legitimacy: the cases of Iraq and Afghanistan
Auteur:
Roy, Olivier
Verschenen in:
Conflict security and development
Paginering:
Jaargang 4 (2004) nr. 2 pagina's 167-179
Jaar:
2004-08
Inhoud:
Development's policies are based on a set of premises: state-building, state of law, democratisation, accountability and privatisation. The idea is that the Western concept of democracy could be implemented through the development of a 'civil society' of the building from scratch of new institutions. Such a model works when there is political will from the local political authorities and the society to adopt such a model (as was the case in Poland and Hungary after the collapse of the Soviet Union). But in any case a policy of development should be based on political legitimacy. In Iraq, as well as Afghanistan, political legitimacy means abiding with nationalism, Islam and local political culture (often based on clan-ism and networks). In Iraq, the US policy has deliberately ignored the issue of legitimacy. In Afghanistan, because the US intervention was not part of a great design, it relied more on local constraints and thus has been more effective, or at least, less disruptive. The issue is not opposing a Western model of democracy to a national authoritarian political culture, but to root democracy into the local political culture. If not the policy of strengthening civil society, through political and military pressure as well as NGO's, has a disruptive effect and may lead to a conservative, nationalist and religious backlash.
Tijdschrift beschrijving