Inevitability, masculinity, and the American military tradition: the committee on the conduct of the war investigates the American Civil War
Titel:
Inevitability, masculinity, and the American military tradition: the committee on the conduct of the war investigates the American Civil War
Auteur:
Tap, Bruce
Verschenen in:
American nineteenth century history
Paginering:
Jaargang 5 (2004) nr. 2 pagina's 19-46
Jaar:
2004
Inhoud:
This essay examines the work of the Joint Committee on the Conduct of the War, a joint select committee of investigation formed by Congress during the American Civil War. During its tenure in the 37th and 38th sessions of Congress, the Committee investigated almost every aspect of Union military operations; however, its principal concern was the examination of Union military defeats. Members of the Committee on the Conduct of the War were influenced by the notion of inevitable Union victory. As self-made men who had achieved a degree of success in the emerging market economy of nineteenth-century America, Committee members exemplified the period's predominate concept of masculinity. Also skeptical of military science and distrustful of the United States military academy at West Point, the Committee showed a marked preference for volunteer soldiers and officers throughout the war. Believing that West Point generals who endorsed strategic maneuver were cowardly and disloyal, Committee members were frequently critical of regular army officers in their investigations. Confusing the rhetoric of 'hard war' with military competence, the Committee's disdain for military education caused it to endorse incompetent military leadership and advocate mediocre generals for high command.
Tijdschrift beschrijving